Bot reviewers (cubic + cursor) flagged 5 follow-on issues after the
first fix push. Three are real bugs in the Phase 6-8 ensure_indices
sidecar wiring; two are AI-slop flags on shallow tests. One cursor
finding is a false positive on intentional node/edge index asymmetry.
Real bugs fixed:
- needs_index_work_node and needs_index_work_edge now skip empty
tables (count_rows == 0). The ensure_indices_for_branch loop has
`if row_count > 0 { build_indices(...) }`, so empty tables produce
zero commit_staged calls. Pinning them in the sidecar would force
NoMovement classification on recovery and trigger the all-or-nothing
rollback of any sibling table's legitimate index work (cubic #1).
- needs_index_work_node and needs_index_work_edge now respect the
table_branch parameter from the snapshot entry, instead of always
passing None (== main). For branch writes, opening the wrong HEAD
could miss recoverable Phase B commits (cubic #2).
- needs_index_work_edge documented as intentionally BTree-only (mirrors
the build_indices_on_dataset_for_catalog edge branch which only
builds id/src/dst BTrees). Cursor flagged FTS/vector omission as
inconsistency with the node helper; confirmed intentional via
inline comment so future readers know the asymmetry is on purpose
(cursor finding, false positive marked).
Test improvements:
- recovery_multi_sidecar_requires_fresh_snapshot_for_correctness — new
integration test that uses TWO sidecars on the SAME table where
sidecar B's expected_version equals sidecar A's post_commit_pin.
Sidecar B's classification only succeeds if the recovery sweep
refreshes the snapshot between iterations to see A's manifest
update. Without the refresh fix from the prior commit, B would be
classified against stale pins (cubic #4 follow-up).
- recovery_ensure_indices_handles_empty_tables — new integration test
that runs ensure_indices on an all-empty repo. With the round-2 fix,
both initial and steady-state runs leave no sidecar (zero pins ⇒
zero sidecar I/O). Without the empty-table fix, the sidecar would
pin Company (zero rows but missing indices) and force a NoMovement
rollback (cubic #1 verification).
- ensure_indices_phase_b_failure_does_not_leak_sidecar_when_no_work_needed —
renamed/rewrote the prior `_recovered_on_next_open` test to assert
the post-fix invariant: when load_jsonl auto-built every catalog
index via prepare_updates_for_commit, ensure_indices's needs_work
helpers correctly report zero pins and produce no sidecar. The old
assertion ("exactly one sidecar must persist") was wrong for the
scoped behavior.
Test surface (post-round-2):
- 25 unit tests in db::manifest::recovery (BranchMerge classifier,
sort order, primitives — unchanged).
- 12 integration tests in tests/recovery.rs (+2 from this commit).
- 11 failpoint tests including the four per-writer Phase B → recovery
tests (one renamed to reflect the scoped behavior).
- ~672 workspace tests pass with --features failpoints.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Bot reviewers (cubic, cursor, chatgpt-codex) caught 4 merge-blocking
bugs + 3 strongly-recommended fixes + 3 doc errors in the initial PR.
Each fix has a paired test demonstrating the bug before the fix.
Merge-blocking fixes:
- BranchMerge moved to loose-match classifier arm. publish_rewritten_
merge_table runs multiple commit_staged calls per table (merge_insert
+ delete_where + index rebuilds). Strict classification rolled back
valid completed Phase B work as UnexpectedMultistep. Three new unit
tests pin the loose-match behavior for BranchMerge.
- branch_merge sidecar uses self.active_branch() (the resolved target
branch) instead of inferring from the first sorted table key. The
previous heuristic could record None (== main) when the merge target
was a non-main branch, causing recovery to publish to the wrong
manifest namespace.
- Best-effort sidecar delete in all 5 writer sites (mutation, loader,
schema_apply, branch_merge, ensure_indices). Previously, a sidecar
cleanup failure after a successful manifest publish would error out
the user's call for a write that already landed. Now: log a warning
and ignore — the next open's recovery sweep tidies the stale sidecar
via NoMovement classification.
- ensure_indices sidecar scoped to tables that need work via new
helpers needs_index_work_node / needs_index_work_edge. Previously
the sidecar pinned every catalog table; if only one needed indexing,
the others classified as NoMovement and the all-or-nothing decision
rolled back legitimate index work.
Strongly-recommended fixes:
- recover_manifest_drift now takes &mut GraphCoordinator and refreshes
between sidecars. Sidecar B's classification needs to see sidecar
A's manifest changes, otherwise B can be classified against stale
pins and incorrectly roll back work that just landed.
- list_sidecars sorts URIs before reading. Sidecar filenames are
ULIDs (chronologically sortable), so this gives deterministic,
time-ordered processing. Filesystem-order was nondeterministic.
- ReadOnly opens skip recover_schema_state_files too (was: only the
MR-847 sweep was gated). Read-only consumers may run with read-only
credentials; silent open-time mutations violate the contract.
Doc cleanups:
- Removed stale "Phase 4 placeholder" comment from
recover_manifest_drift.
- docs/runs.md decision-tree wording now correctly surfaces the
InvariantViolation abort path.
- docs/branches-commits.md clarifies actor_id is in
_graph_commit_actors.lance (joined by graph_commit_id), not on
_graph_commits.lance itself.
Test surface (post-fixes):
- 25 unit tests in db::manifest::recovery (+4 from this commit).
- 10 integration tests in tests/recovery.rs (+3 from this commit).
- ~672 tests across ~25 binaries pass with --features failpoints.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Update the doc surface to reflect MR-847 having shipped end to end —
sidecar protocol, classifier, all-or-nothing decision tree, roll-forward
via ManifestBatchPublisher, roll-back via Dataset::restore with
fragment-set short-circuit, audit trail in
_graph_commit_recoveries.lance, OpenMode::{ReadWrite, ReadOnly}, and
the four migrated writers all carrying sidecars across Phase B → Phase C.
- docs/invariants.md §VI.23: change from "upheld at the writer-trait
surface for inserts/updates/etc., per-table commit_staged → manifest
publish window remains" to "upheld at the writer-trait surface AND
across process boundaries". The MR-847 sweep closes the residual on
the next Omnigraph::open. The "continuous in-process" property
(no ExpectedVersionMismatch surfacing to subsequent writers between
Phase B failure and process restart) is honest follow-up at MR-856.
- docs/runs.md: replace "Finalize → publisher residual" section with
"Open-time recovery sweep (MR-847)" — describes the sidecar protocol
lifecycle (Phases A-D), the sweep's classifier + decision dispatch,
the audit trail, and the operator-facing query
(omnigraph commit list --filter actor=omnigraph:recovery).
- AGENTS.md capability matrix "Atomic single-dataset commits" row:
drop the "Layer (3) is not yet shipped — tracked in MR-847" caveat;
describe the three layers as all shipping; reference MR-856 for the
background-reconciler follow-up.
- docs/storage.md: add _graph_commit_recoveries.lance and
__recovery/{ulid}.json to the on-disk layout (mermaid + prose).
- docs/branches-commits.md: new "Recovery audit trail (MR-847)"
subsection describing the join from
_graph_commits.lance:actor_id="omnigraph:recovery" to
_graph_commit_recoveries.lance:graph_commit_id for operator
post-mortem.
- docs/maintenance.md: note the MR-847 recovery floor on cleanup —
--keep < 3 may garbage-collect Lance versions the recovery sweep
needs as a rollback target. Default --keep 10 is safe.
- docs/testing.md: add tests/recovery.rs to the engine integration-test
table; expand the failpoints.rs row to mention the four MR-847
per-writer Phase B → recovery integration tests.
- .context/mr-847-design.md: prepend a "Status: DONE" stanza listing
every commit hash + scope across phases 1-10.
AGENTS.md ↔ docs/ cross-link check passes (26 links, 26 docs).
Full workspace test sweep passes with --features failpoints (361 tests
across 20 binaries).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Add the three paired per-writer tests required by MR-847's acceptance
criteria — "All four migrated writers ... have paired Phase B → recovery
integration tests."
Production additions (~10 LOC):
- New failpoint `branch_merge.post_phase_b_pre_manifest_commit` in
`exec/merge.rs::branch_merge_on_current_target` between the per-table
publish loop and `commit_manifest_updates`.
- New failpoint `ensure_indices.post_phase_b_pre_manifest_commit` in
`db/omnigraph/table_ops.rs::ensure_indices_for_branch` between the
per-table loops and `commit_prepared_updates_on_branch`.
- For schema_apply, the existing `schema_apply.after_staging_write`
failpoint already fires in the right window (after the per-table
rewrites + index builds, before the manifest publish).
Sidecar tweak:
- `schema_apply` sidecar's `branch` is now `None` (was
`Some("__schema_apply_lock__")`). The lock branch is purely a
serialization sentinel; `coordinator.commit_changes_with_actor`
publishes against the coordinator's pre-lock branch (main). After
the failpoint fires, `release_schema_apply_lock` removes the lock
branch — if the sidecar referenced it, the recovery sweep would try
to publish to a branch that no longer exists and fail. Fix: record
the actual publish target.
Tests added in `tests/failpoints.rs` (~280 LOC):
- `schema_apply_phase_b_failure_recovered_on_next_open` — seeds a row,
opens, attempts a schema apply that adds a new node type + a new
property (the new type ensures the table set differs so
`recover_schema_state_files` doesn't trip on property-only
ambiguity), failpoint fires, drops engine, reopens, asserts sidecar
deleted + audit row recorded.
- `branch_merge_phase_b_failure_recovered_on_next_open` — seeds main,
branches off, mutates the branch, attempts merge with the
`branch_merge.post_phase_b_pre_manifest_commit` failpoint active.
Same recovery shape.
- `ensure_indices_phase_b_failure_recovered_on_next_open` — seeds
rows, attempts ensure_indices with the
`ensure_indices.post_phase_b_pre_manifest_commit` failpoint active.
After this commit, all four migrated writers have paired
Phase B → recovery tests:
- mutate_as / load: `recovery_rolls_forward_after_finalize_publisher_failure` (Phase 5)
- schema_apply: `schema_apply_phase_b_failure_recovered_on_next_open`
- branch_merge: `branch_merge_phase_b_failure_recovered_on_next_open`
- ensure_indices: `ensure_indices_phase_b_failure_recovered_on_next_open`
11 failpoint tests pass; full workspace lib + integration tests pass
(350+ tests across 20 binaries).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Three writers each follow the same shape established in Phase 5: build
SidecarTablePin list before the per-table commit_staged loop, write the
sidecar via recovery::write_sidecar, do the existing work, delete the
sidecar after the manifest publish succeeds.
Loose-match classifier (recovery.rs):
The classifier now distinguishes strict vs. loose match per
SidecarKind. Strict (Mutation, Load, BranchMerge): exactly one
commit_staged per table; lance_head == manifest_pinned + 1 AND
post_commit_pin == lance_head required. Loose (SchemaApply,
EnsureIndices): the writer may run N >= 1 commit_staged calls per
table — index builds + rewrites compound, and the exact N is hard to
compute at sidecar-write time. Loose accepts any
lance_head > manifest_pinned (with expected_version still matching the
manifest pin) as RolledPastExpected. The risk it admits — an external
agent advancing HEAD between sidecar write and recovery — is out of
scope for the single-coordinator model (MR-668 territory).
roll_forward_all now reads the CURRENT Lance HEAD per table (not the
sidecar's post_commit_pin) so the manifest publish reflects whatever
HEAD landed, even if the loose-match writer committed multiple times
per table.
Per-writer wiring:
- schema_apply::apply_schema_with_lock: sidecar covers
rewritten_tables ∪ indexed_tables (the tables that go through
stage_overwrite/stage_create_index commit_staged). Skips
added_tables (fresh datasets, no Phase B residual class) and
renamed_tables (handled by the existing schema-state staging
recovery in recover_schema_state_files).
- branch_merge::branch_merge_on_current_target: sidecar covers every
table in candidates (publish_adopted_source_state +
publish_rewritten_merge_table do the per-table commit_staged work).
Sidecar writes after validate_merge_candidates and deletes after
commit_manifest_updates.
- ensure_indices_for_branch: sidecar covers every node + edge type in
the catalog with a manifest entry (build_indices_on_dataset is
per-table-per-index commit_staged). Skips when the catalog has
nothing — steady-state calls incur no sidecar I/O when the manifest
already pins all expected types.
Allow recovery_audit.rs in forbidden_apis.rs:
The new db/recovery_audit.rs uses Dataset::write to bootstrap the
_graph_commit_recoveries.lance dataset (same pattern as
commit_graph.rs which is already allow-listed). Add it to the
ALLOW_LIST_FILES list in tests/forbidden_apis.rs.
8 new unit tests in db::manifest::recovery cover the loose-match
classifier branches (SchemaApply + EnsureIndices accept multi-commit
drift, NoMovement and InvariantViolation behave the same as strict).
All 20 test binaries pass (350+ tests across the workspace).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Production wiring (~120 LOC):
- `MutationStaging::finalize` now takes a `SidecarKind` parameter and
returns an additional `Option<RecoverySidecarHandle>`. Builds a
Vec<SidecarTablePin> from `pending` BEFORE the per-table commit_staged
loop and writes the sidecar via `recovery::write_sidecar`. Skips the
sidecar when `pending` is empty (delete-only mutation; D₂ keeps these
out of the staged-write path so the option is just a clean signal,
not a code path users hit).
- `exec/mutation.rs::execute_mutation_as` (around line 740): destructure
the new third element, pass `SidecarKind::Mutation`, delete the
sidecar after `commit_updates_on_branch_with_expected` succeeds.
- `loader/mod.rs::ingest_loaded` (around line 540): same shape, with
`SidecarKind::Load`. The Overwrite path stays inline-commit (legacy
residual; out of MR-847 scope per docs/runs.md).
- New engine accessors `Omnigraph::storage_adapter()` and
`Omnigraph::root_uri()` for the sidecar I/O. The pre-existing
`db.storage` field stays private; no other engine code reaches around
the accessor.
- Re-exports from `db::manifest`: `new_sidecar`, `write_sidecar`,
`delete_sidecar`, plus the `RecoverySidecar*` types and `SidecarKind`,
so consumers in `exec/` can use them via `crate::db::manifest::...`.
Bugfix folded in (~5 LOC): make `coordinator` mutable in
`Omnigraph::open_with_storage_and_mode` and call `coordinator.refresh()`
after the recovery sweep returns. Roll-forward advances the manifest
pin on disk; without the refresh the returned engine carried a stale
in-memory snapshot. The Phase 4 tests passed only because they
opened Lance datasets directly rather than going through `db.snapshot()`.
Storage adapter (~15 LOC): `LocalStorageAdapter::write_text` now ensures
the parent directory exists via `tokio::fs::create_dir_all`. Required
because the sidecar protocol writes into `__recovery/` which doesn't
pre-exist after `Omnigraph::init`. S3 has no equivalent; PutObject is
path-agnostic.
Headline test flip (~150 LOC):
- `tests/failpoints.rs::finalize_publisher_residual_drifts_lance_head_until_next_writer_recovers`
is replaced by `recovery_rolls_forward_after_finalize_publisher_failure`.
Same setup (failpoint at `mutation.post_finalize_pre_publisher`) but
after the synthetic failure the test:
1. Asserts the sidecar persists in `__recovery/` for the recovery
sweep to find.
2. Drops the engine handle.
3. Reopens via `Omnigraph::open` — recovery sweep classifies
RolledPastExpected, decides RollForward, publishes the manifest
update, records the audit row, deletes the sidecar.
4. Asserts the sidecar is gone.
5. Asserts the originally-attempted Eve insert is now visible
(Person count = 1).
6. Asserts a subsequent insert succeeds without
ExpectedVersionMismatch (Person count = 2).
7. Asserts the audit dataset `_graph_commit_recoveries.lance` exists.
This is the headline contract the MR-847 acceptance criteria require.
All other failpoint and runs tests continue to pass (8 + 24 unchanged).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Implement the remaining half of the open-time recovery sweep.
Roll-forward execution (db/manifest/recovery.rs::roll_forward_all):
constructs a GraphNamespacePublisher directly (recovery runs inside
Omnigraph::open before the engine struct exists, so we can't go through
Omnigraph::commit_updates_on_branch_with_expected). Builds a
ManifestChange::Update per sidecar table reading row_count and
TableVersionMetadata from the dataset at post_commit_pin (cheap;
manifest-level reads, not a row scan), then calls publisher.publish with
expected_table_versions = sidecar.expected_version per table. Single
__manifest CAS extends every pin atomically — all-or-nothing at the
substrate. Persistent CAS contention surfaces as the typed
ExpectedVersionMismatch error and leaves the sidecar in place for the
next open's retry.
Audit model (new crates/omnigraph/src/db/recovery_audit.rs +
record_audit() in recovery.rs): each successful recovery sweep records
a graph-commit row tagged with actor_id="omnigraph:recovery" plus a
row in a new sibling table _graph_commit_recoveries.lance carrying
recovery_kind (RolledForward | RolledBack), recovery_for_actor (the
sidecar's original actor_id), operation_id (sidecar ULID),
sidecar_writer_kind, per_table_outcomes (JSON-serialized for schema
flexibility), and created_at. Operators investigating "did my mutation
land?" can find the answer via `omnigraph commit list --filter
actor=omnigraph:recovery` joined to the recoveries table by
graph_commit_id.
The sibling-table choice avoids bumping INTERNAL_MANIFEST_SCHEMA_VERSION
or migrating _graph_commits.lance. Same not-atomic-pair-write shape as
the existing _graph_commits + _graph_commit_actors split — a crash
between the two sequential writes leaves an orphan commit row with no
recovery row. Recovery sweep tolerates this: re-entry classifies
already-restored / already-published tables as NoMovement, the action
is a no-op, and the audit append is retried.
Note on classifier: process_sidecar's RollBack arm now restores
RolledPastExpected, UnexpectedAtP1, AND UnexpectedMultistep (any drift
class). Earlier Phase 3 logic restricted to RolledPastExpected only,
which left UnexpectedAtP1/UnexpectedMultistep tables drifted; the
all-or-nothing decision rule per docs/invariants.md §VI.23 demands all
drifted tables be restored.
3 new integration tests in tests/recovery.rs (7 total now):
- recovery_rolls_forward_after_phase_b_completes — happy-path
roll-forward; audit row recorded; idempotent on second open.
- recovery_rolls_back_records_audit_row_with_recovery_actor —
roll-back path also records an audit row with the original actor.
- recovery_rolls_forward_with_null_actor — sidecar without actor_id
still records the audit row (recovery_for_actor = None).
3 new unit tests in db::recovery_audit pin the round-trip + persistence
+ recovery_kind string parsing.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Add `OpenMode::{ReadWrite, ReadOnly}` and route `Omnigraph::open` through
`open_with_storage_and_mode`. Recovery sweep runs only under
`OpenMode::ReadWrite` — read-only consumers (NDJSON export, commit list,
schema show) skip it via `Omnigraph::open_read_only`. Rationale: the
sweep performs Lance writes (Dataset::restore, manifest publish); a
read-only consumer with read-only object-store credentials shouldn't
trigger writes, and reads always resolve through the manifest pin
regardless of any drift on the per-table side.
`recover_manifest_drift` lands in db/manifest/recovery.rs and is wired
into Omnigraph::open AFTER recover_schema_state_files — schema-state
recovery operates on staging files; manifest-drift recovery operates on
Lance HEADs that may depend on schema-state being settled.
Roll-back path is fully implemented: classify each table per the
sidecar's intent, dispatch the all-or-nothing decision, and call
restore_table_to_version for any table with drift (RolledPastExpected,
UnexpectedAtP1, or UnexpectedMultistep). NoMovement tables are already
at expected_version — no action. Sidecar deleted as the final step.
Roll-forward path errors with a Phase-4 placeholder so it surfaces
loudly if reached without the audit + manifest-publish wiring landing
first.
Concurrency: today (pre-MR-686) recovery is naturally serialized by the
single-coordinator model. Open runs at server startup BEFORE
Arc<RwLock<Omnigraph>> wraps the engine (lib.rs:194), so no request
handlers can race. CLI is sequential by caller orchestration. Under
MR-686's per-(table_key, branch) queues + MR-856 (background recovery
reconciler), the queue acquisition will need to extend to recovery
sweeps — handoff documented on MR-686 ticket and in MR-856.
4 integration tests in tests/recovery.rs pin the Phase 3 contract:
- recovery_does_not_run_on_clean_open — no sidecars; sweep is a no-op.
- recovery_refuses_unknown_schema_version_on_open — sidecar v=99
surfaces SidecarSchemaError and is left on disk for operator review.
- read_only_open_skips_recovery_sweep — even a sidecar with bogus
table_path doesn't get classified under OpenMode::ReadOnly.
- recovery_rolls_back_synthetic_drift_on_open — sidecar with mismatched
post_commit_pin classifies as UnexpectedAtP1, decision is RollBack,
restore is invoked, sidecar is deleted, idempotent on second open.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Two new tests in tests/staged_writes.rs that the recovery sweep design
depends on:
- lance_restore_appends_one_commit_with_checked_out_content — verifies
Dataset::restore() (no-args; restores currently-checked-out version)
produces HEAD+1, not HEAD+2 as the v1 design assumed. Source confirmed
at lance-4.0.0/src/dataset.rs:1106; this test prevents a future lance
bump from silently breaking the recovery rollback math.
- lance_restore_loses_to_concurrent_append_via_orphaning — pins the
concurrency hazard motivating MR-847's open-time-only invocation
strategy: check_restore_txn (lance-4.0.0/src/io/commit/conflict_
resolver.rs:986) returns Ok against Append/Update/Delete/CreateIndex/
Merge/etc., so a Restore commits successfully even when a concurrent
legitimate writer just landed an Append — silently orphaning the
Append's data from the active timeline. MR-847 sidesteps via running
recovery only at Omnigraph::open (before any other writers race);
MR-856 (continuous-recovery reconciler) must guard via per-(table,
branch) queue acquisition once MR-686 lands.
These two tests together pin the foundation for MR-847's correctness
claims and document the load-bearing constraint MR-856 will inherit.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Closes MR-793 acceptance §1 via option (b): every inline-commit method
remaining on the trait surface is named, the upstream blocker or
internal phase that closes it is cited, and the call-site residual
comment is mandated.
Reframes the criterion text in the MR-793 ticket comment from "either
full sealing OR all residuals enumerated" — this commit ships the
"enumerated" path. The "full sealing" path (Phase 1b + Phase 9 + the
two Lance upstream tickets) closes the matrix entirely.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Fetched https://lance.org/format/table/mem_wal/ in full via npx mdrip.
The "Overview / Details / Implementation" sidebar items turned out to
be anchor sections on the same URL, not separate pages.
Key findings (relevant to MR-847's recovery reconciler design):
* MemWAL is opt-in. Requires (1) unenforced primary key in schema,
(2) explicit shard config, (3) writers using the LSM-tree write
path. omnigraph does NOT enable it; we use direct write_fragments +
commit(Operation::Append).
* MemWAL is intra-table — addresses streaming-write throughput for
one Lance base table via MemTables → flushed MemTables → async
merge. It does not coordinate across multiple tables.
* MemWAL's recovery is intra-table: WAL replay reconstructs MemTable
state for one table. It does NOT help with omnigraph's cross-table
manifest-pinned-vs-Lance-HEAD drift class.
Conclusion: MR-847's recovery reconciler design is unaffected. The
two operate at different abstraction layers.
Borrowable: MemWAL's epoch-based fencing pattern is structurally
similar to a future multi-coordinator sidecar protocol; noted on
MR-847 for if MR-668 (multi-process) ever lands.
External reviewer flagged that the capability matrix's "Atomic
multi-dataset publish" cell implied Lance gives us a single primitive
for cross-table atomicity. It doesn't. The real contract is three
layers stacked:
(1) per-table Lance `commit_staged` for the data write
(2) `__manifest` row-level CAS via `ManifestBatchPublisher` for
cross-table ordering
(3) recovery-on-open reconciler for the residual gap between (1)
and (2) — NOT YET SHIPPED, tracked in MR-847.
Until MR-847 lands, a failure between per-table `commit_staged` and
the manifest publish leaves drift on the partially-committed tables
(the "Phase B → Phase C residual" documented in `docs/runs.md`).
Also enumerate the legacy inline-commit residuals (`append_batch`,
`merge_insert_batches`, `overwrite_batch`, `create_*_index`) alongside
`delete_where` and `create_vector_index` — they remain on the trait
pending Phase 1b call-site conversion + Phase 9 demotion.
End the row with an explicit DO NOT: future agents reading the
capability matrix should not describe atomicity as "fully upheld"
until MR-847 ships.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Cubic flagged that the guard misses `ds.append() / ds.delete() / ds.restore()`.
`.restore(` is added — Lance-specific (no false positives in the
workspace).
`.append(` and `.delete(` stay excluded with a documenting comment:
* `.append(` over-matches `Vec::append`, `String::append`, every
`arrow_array::xxxArrayBuilder::append` (30+ legit uses across
`exec/mutation.rs`, `loader/jsonl.rs`, `exec/projection.rs`).
* `.delete(` over-matches `ObjectStore::delete` (used in `storage.rs`,
`db/schema_state.rs`, `db/omnigraph.rs:1277` for staging-file
cleanup) and would require many `// forbidden-api-allow:` sentinels
for legitimate uses.
The remaining bypass route — engine code that imports `lance::Dataset`
and calls `ds.append(reader, params)` — is bounded by:
1. The trait surface itself (sealed, only-callable-via-trait once
Phase 1b call-site conversion completes).
2. The PR-review process catching new `lance::Dataset` imports in
non-storage files.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Cubic findings:
* `tests/forbidden_apis.rs`: expand `FORBIDDEN_PATTERNS` with `Dataset::write`
/ `Dataset::append` / `Dataset::delete` / `Dataset::merge_insert` /
`Dataset::add_columns` / `update_columns` / `drop_columns` /
`truncate_table` / `restore` and the bare `.merge_insert(` /
`.add_columns(` / `.update_columns(` / `.drop_columns(` /
`.truncate_table(` method patterns. Deliberately avoid `.append(` /
`.delete(` / `.write(` (over-match `Vec::append`, `.delete_branch(`,
arrow-array `.append(`, etc.). Allow-list `commit_graph.rs` and
`graph_coordinator.rs` — they're manifest-layer infra that legitimately
uses `Dataset::write` for system tables.
* `schema_apply.rs:253`: pass `entry.table_branch.as_deref()` (not
`None`) to `open_dataset_head_for_write` for consistency with the
sibling `indexed_tables` block. Schema apply rejects non-main
branches at the lock-acquire step today, so behavior is unchanged;
this is a defensive consistency fix that survives a future relaxation
of the lock check.
* `storage_layer.rs:131` doc: was `Vec<&StagedWrite>` with lifetime
claim; actually returns `Vec<StagedWrite>` (cloned). Fixed.
* `AGENTS.md:201` capability matrix row + `storage_layer.rs:1` module
doc: softened the "stage_* + commit_staged are the only paths" /
"trait funnels every write" overclaim. Inline-commit residuals
(`delete_where`, `create_vector_index`) remain on the trait pending
upstream Lance work (#6658, #6666); legacy `append_batch` etc.
remain pending Phase 1b / Phase 9. Module doc now describes the
current transitional state honestly.
Cursor Bugbot findings:
* `storage_layer.rs:360`: trait `delete_where` consumed `SnapshotHandle`
but returned only `DeleteState`, dropping the post-delete dataset.
Future callers migrating from the inherent `&mut Dataset` API would
lose the post-delete dataset state needed for indexing /
`table_state` queries. Fixed: returns `(SnapshotHandle, DeleteState)`
matching `append_batch` / `overwrite_batch` shape.
* `storage_layer.rs:824`: removed dead `_scanner_type_marker` fn and
the unused `Scanner` import (the marker existed only to suppress an
unused-import warning — fixing the import is the cleaner answer).
Engine-level Phase A failpoint test (closes the partial-criterion
flagged in Cubic's acceptance-criteria checklist):
* `db/omnigraph/table_ops.rs::stage_and_commit_btree`: instrumented
with `crate::failpoints::maybe_fail("ensure_indices.post_stage_pre_commit_btree")`
between `stage_create_btree_index` and `commit_staged`.
* `tests/failpoints.rs::ensure_indices_phase_a_btree_failure_leaves_existing_tables_writable`:
triggers the failpoint via a schema-apply that adds a new node type;
proves that existing tables are unaffected (Person mutation succeeds
after the failed apply) — i.e. Phase A failure leaves no Lance-HEAD
drift on tables outside the failed `added_tables` iteration.
`docs/invariants.md` transitional notes:
* §VI.23 (atomicity per query): annotated as upheld at the
writer-trait surface for inserts / updates / scalar-index builds /
merge_insert / overwrite after MR-793 PR #70. Per-table
commit_staged → manifest publish window remains; closing requires
MR-847's recovery-on-open reconciler. `delete_where` and
`create_vector_index` remain inline pending lance#6658 / #6666.
* §VII.35 (reconciler pattern): annotated as partial — staged
primitives are the building blocks; the reconciler task itself is
MR-848.
* §VIII.45 (reference impl per trait): `TableStorage` has its primary
impl on `TableStore` with opaque-handle signatures; no test impl
yet.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Behavior is interlocked across Lance pages — transactions reference
index lifecycle, index lifecycle references compaction, compaction
references row-id lineage. Skipping a "slightly relevant" page is how
alignment misses happen. The index alone is not a substitute for
reading the pages.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Hoists Lance's stage+commit two-phase write pattern from "discipline at
each writer" to a sealed trait surface (`TableStorage`). New engine code
that needs to advance Lance HEAD MUST go through `stage_*` + `commit_staged`;
the trait's opaque `SnapshotHandle` / `StagedHandle` types keep
`lance::Dataset` and `lance::Transaction` out of trait signatures.
Phases landed (see .context/mr-793-design.md for the full plan):
* 1a: `crates/omnigraph/src/storage_layer.rs` — `TableStorage` trait,
sealed (only in-tree types can impl), single impl on `TableStore`
delegating to existing inherent methods; `Omnigraph::storage()`
accessor returns `&dyn TableStorage`.
* 2: three new staged primitives — `stage_overwrite`,
`stage_create_btree_index`, `stage_create_inverted_index` —
implementing the simple branch of Lance's `CreateIndexBuilder::execute`
(scalar indices only; vector indices stay inline because
`build_index_metadata_from_segments` is `pub(crate)` in lance-4.0.0).
Six new tests in `tests/staged_writes.rs` pin both the new primitives
and the inline residuals (`delete_where`, `create_vector_index`).
* 3: `tests/forbidden_apis.rs` — defense-in-depth integration test
walks engine source, fails on direct lance::* inline-commit API use
outside `table_store.rs` / `db/manifest/`. Skips comment lines and
honors `// forbidden-api-allow:` sentinels.
* 4: `ensure_indices` migration — scalar index builds now route through
`stage_create_*_index` + `commit_staged` instead of
`create_*_index(&mut Dataset)`. Vector indices stay inline (residual,
named honestly at the call site).
* 5: `branch_merge::publish_rewritten_merge_table` migration — the
merge_insert phase now uses `stage_merge_insert` + `commit_staged`;
delete phase stays inline (Lance #6658 residual, named honestly).
* 6: `schema_apply` rewritten_tables migration — non-empty rewrites
use `stage_overwrite` + `commit_staged`; empty-batch rewrites stay
inline because `InsertBuilder::execute_uncommitted` rejects empty
data. The narrow inline window is bounded by `__schema_apply_lock__`.
Verified-green test surface:
* `cargo test -p omnigraph-engine` — 68 lib + ~120 integration tests
(incl. 6 new staged_writes tests + the new forbidden_apis test).
* `cargo test -p omnigraph-engine --features failpoints --test failpoints`
— 5 tests, all green.
* `cargo test --workspace` — green.
Deferred to follow-up sessions (see design doc §17 split):
* Phase 1b — convert remaining engine call sites to `&dyn TableStorage`
(mostly READS that don't touch the staged-write invariant).
* Phase 7 — recovery-on-open reconciler (closes Phase B → Phase C
residual across process restarts; new subsystem).
* Phase 8 — index-coverage reconciler (full §VII.35 compliance —
removes synchronous index work from the publish path).
* Phase 9 — demote unused `TableStore` inherent methods to `pub(crate)`
(depends on Phase 1b).
Lance upstream blockers documented:
* lance-format/lance#6658 — two-phase delete API (open, no PRs).
* Companion: `build_index_metadata_from_segments` should be `pub` so
vector-index builds can be staged outside the lance crate.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
OmniGraph is OSS; internal Linear ticket references and code-review-bot
mentions in source-code comments don't help external readers and leak
internal tooling. Replace ticket numbers (MR-XXX) with descriptive
prose, drop linear.app URLs, and remove inline mentions of
Cursor/Bugbot/Cubic/Codex review threads.
Scope is limited to source-code comments (`crates/`). Docs under
`docs/` keep their MR-XXX references — those are part of the
established change-history narrative for in-repo docs and don't
require a Linear account to find context for.
No behavior changes; no public API changes.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Four code/doc fixes from the latest Cursor Bugbot pass:
* **Misplaced doc comment in table_store.rs (Medium):** the doc block
intended for `scan_pending_batches` was, after my earlier edit,
attached to `collect_string_column_values` because the new helper
was inserted between the original docblock and `scan_pending_batches`.
Move the docblock back onto its function and add a note about the
shared SQL-dialect contract with the Lance scanner (the predicate
goes to both, which is fine for `predicate_to_sql`'s plain comparison
shapes today; future Lance-specific scanner extensions in the filter
would need translation).
* **Missing null check on committed `id` column (Low):** the
committed-side loop in `collect_node_ids_with_pending` (and the
parallel non-pending `collect_node_ids`) read `id_col.value(i)`
without `is_valid(i)` first. `id` is the @key column on every node
type and non-nullable by schema, so this is unreachable today, but
the inconsistency with the pending-side `is_valid` guard is worth
closing for symmetry / defense.
* **Misleading comment in count_pending_src_with_dedupe (Low):** the
comment claimed "fall back to naive counting" but the code did
`continue`. Fix: it's unreachable in practice (the pending-side
schema always contains the key when the caller passes one), so
failing loudly with a typed error if it ever does fire is correct
— silently skipping the batch would let `@card` violations slip
past validation.
* **PendingTable.schema mismatch surfaces too late (Medium):**
PendingTable captures the schema from the first batch and never
updates it. On a blob-bearing table, `insert` produces a full-schema
batch and `update` (without assigning every blob) produces a
subset-schema batch. Pre-fix the mismatch surfaced inside
finalize/MemTable construction — distant from the offending op.
Post-fix `MutationStaging::append_batch` validates the new batch's
schema against the existing accumulator's schema and returns a
typed error directing the caller to split the mutation. Error
fires at the offending op, not at end-of-query. New helper
`schemas_compatible` compares field name + data_type pairs;
nullability and field metadata differences stay tolerated (downstream
concat already permits those).
Cubic Cursor Bugbot finding #5 (cascade delete edge re-open) self-resolved
in the bot's own analysis ("logic appears sound on re-examination") —
no action.
New test on tests/runs.rs:
* append_batch_rejects_mismatched_schema_in_blob_table_at_offending_op
— pins the early-error path. Builds a blob-bearing schema, runs an
`insert + update` query where the update doesn't assign the blob,
asserts the error fires at the second op with the "Split the
mutation" message and the manifest is unchanged.
Local: tests/runs.rs 24/24 passed.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
The standalone test_failpoints_feature job took 21min on first run
(cold cache; the omnigraph-engine crate has lance + datafusion deps
that make any fresh build expensive). Folding into Test Workspace
shares the warm cache so the failpoints invocation is incremental —
~30s vs 21min on subsequent runs, and within the workspace job's
existing budget.
The failpoints feature is gated behind a Cargo flag and only adds
the small `fail` crate dep + a few feature-gated code paths; it
doesn't change the dep tree of any other crate.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Three new findings from Cubic on commit 3223b51:
* **Pending edge cardinality counted within-input duplicates** (P2):
count_src_per_edge's pending walk added every row to the count,
including duplicate rows that finalize will collapse via
dedupe_merge_batches_by_id. A LoadMode::Merge with the same edge id
twice would over-count → spurious @card violation. Fix: when
dedupe_key_column is Some, walk pending in reverse, track seen keys
via HashSet, count only the kept (last-occurrence) rows. Mirrors
finalize-time dedupe so cardinality counts what stage_merge_insert
actually publishes.
* **scan_with_pending silently disabled merge-shadow when projection
omitted key_column** (P2): if a caller passed Some("id") as
key_column but their projection didn't include "id", the
filter_out_rows_where_string_in helper passed batches through
unchanged — silently degrading to union semantics. Fix: validate
up front that projection contains key_column when both are Some;
return a typed Lance error otherwise. Tightened the helper too:
missing column is now an internal error (was a silent passthrough).
* **Cascade-vs-explicit delete test was too weak** (P2): asserted
only that edge count decreased after delete. The cascade alone
could satisfy that even if the explicit second-delete silently
no-op'd. Strengthened: assert post_knows == 0, which only holds
when both ops landed (Bob→Diana would survive if op-2 no-op'd).
CI gap: also added test_failpoints_feature job to .github/workflows/ci.yml.
The workspace test runs without --features failpoints (the feature is
behind a Cargo flag), so the failpoints test suite was never exercised
by CI before now. The new job builds + runs
`cargo test -p omnigraph-engine --features failpoints --test failpoints`
on every full CI run, mirroring the test_aws_feature pattern.
New tests on tests/runs.rs:
* load_merge_mode_dedupes_within_pending_for_cardinality_count
(Cubic P2 #2 — pending-vs-pending dedup, distinct from the
load_merge_mode_dedupes_edge_for_cardinality_count test which
covers committed-vs-pending dedup).
* scan_with_pending_rejects_key_column_missing_from_projection
(Cubic P2 #3 — verifies the up-front validation rejects bad
callers and that the happy path still works correctly).
Local test results:
* tests/runs.rs: 23/23 passed
* tests/failpoints.rs --features failpoints: 7/7 passed (includes the
two new finalize→publisher residual tests landed in 3223b51).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Add a Community section to the README with the Omnigraph Slack invite so contributors and users have a clear place to ask questions and share feedback.
Five fixes from PR #68 review (Cursor Bugbot + Codex + Cubic):
* **scan_with_pending gains merge-shadow semantics** (Codex P1, Cubic P1#1):
new `key_column: Option<&str>` parameter. When set, committed rows
whose key value appears in any pending batch are excluded from the
scan — making `scan_with_pending` correctly merge-semantic for chained
updates instead of naively unioning. execute_update calls with
Some("id"). Without this, a chained `update where age > 30` could
match a row whose pending value already moved out of range.
* **Multi-delete on same table no longer trips ExpectedVersionMismatch**
(Cursor Bugbot HIGH): open_table_for_mutation routes through
reopen_for_mutation when staging.inline_committed has the table,
using the post-inline-commit Lance version captured at record_inline
time. The legacy open_for_mutation_on_branch fence (Lance HEAD ==
manifest pinned) is correct cross-writer but wrong intra-query when
deletes have already advanced HEAD on this table. Branch goes away
when Lance ships two-phase delete (lance-format/lance#6658).
* **Cardinality validation consolidated** (Cursor LOW + Codex P2 +
Cubic P1#2 + Cubic P2): new exec/staging::count_src_per_edge +
enforce_cardinality_bounds shared by mutation and loader paths.
Restores the missing min-cardinality check on the engine path.
Loader Merge mode passes Some("id") to dedupe edges being updated
by id (not double-count committed + pending). Loader Append mode
and engine path pass None (ULID-generated ids never collide).
* **Dead count_rows_with_pending removed** (Cursor LOW): never called.
* **Misleading concat-helper comment fixed** (Cubic P3): claimed
schema normalization the helper doesn't implement. Updated to match
reality.
* **Documentation honesty** (Cubic P1#3): MR-794 narrows but doesn't
eliminate the "Lance HEAD ahead of __manifest" drift class. Drift is
unreachable for op-execution failures (the partial_failure test pins
this), but a residual remains at the finalize→publisher boundary
because Lance has no multi-dataset commit primitive: per-table
commit_staged calls run sequentially before manifest commit. Updated
docs/runs.md, docs/invariants.md §VI.25, docs/releases/v0.4.1.md to
scope the claim precisely.
* **Failpoint test pinning the residual**: new
mutation.post_finalize_pre_publisher failpoint + two tests in
tests/failpoints.rs that confirm the documented residual behavior.
Catches future regressions that widen the residual.
Test additions on tests/runs.rs:
* chained_updates_with_overlapping_predicate_respects_intermediate_value
* multi_statement_delete_on_same_node_table
* cascade_delete_node_then_explicit_delete_edge_on_same_table
* mutation_insert_edge_enforces_min_cardinality
* load_merge_mode_dedupes_edge_for_cardinality_count
113/113 engine integration tests pass (runs + end_to_end + consistency
+ staged_writes + validators). Failpoints feature build runs in CI.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Refresh user-facing and agent-facing docs for the staged-write rewire
and clean up stale Run-state-machine references that survived MR-771.
MR-794-specific updates:
* docs/runs.md — remove "Known limitation: mid-query partial failure"
section; document the in-memory accumulator + D₂ rule + the
LoadMode::Overwrite residual.
* docs/invariants.md §VI.25 — flip from aspirational/open to
upheld for inserts/updates. Within-query read-your-writes is now
load-bearing for the publisher CAS contract.
* docs/architecture.md — add "Mutation atomicity — in-memory
accumulator (MR-794)" subsection with per-op flow; refresh the
engine + state diagrams to drop RunRegistry and add MutationStaging.
* docs/execution.md — rewrite the mutation flow sequence diagram
for the staged-write path; updated the LoadMode table to call
out per-mode commit semantics; rewrote load vs ingest.
* docs/query-language.md — document the D₂ parse-time rule.
* docs/errors.md — add the D₂ BadRequest rejection path.
* docs/testing.md — extend the runs.rs row to cover the new MR-794
contract tests; add the staged_writes.rs row.
* docs/releases/v0.4.1.md (new) — release note covering the rewire,
test additions, residuals, and files changed.
* AGENTS.md (CLAUDE.md symlink) — update the atomic-per-query
description and the L2 capability matrix row.
Stale-reference cleanup (MR-771 leftovers):
* docs/storage.md — drop live _graph_runs.lance / _graph_run_actors.lance
from the layout diagram and prose; mark legacy.
* docs/branches-commits.md — move __run__<id> to a legacy note;
remove publish_run from the publish-trigger list.
* docs/audit.md — refresh _as API list (drop begin_run_as / publish_run_as);
legacy RunRecord.actor_id moved to a historical note.
* docs/constants.md — mark run registry / branch-prefix rows as legacy.
* docs/cli.md — replace the legacy omnigraph run * quickstart block
with omnigraph commit list/show.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
load_jsonl_reader dispatches on mode: Append/Merge use the
MutationStaging accumulator (per-type batch staging, single stage_* +
commit_staged per touched table at end-of-load, publisher CAS).
Overwrite keeps the legacy concurrent inline-commit path
(truncate-then-append doesn't fit the staged shape; overwrite has no
in-flight read-your-writes requirement).
* New helpers collect_node_ids_with_pending and
validate_edge_cardinality_with_pending_loader — loader analogs
of the engine's pending-aware validators.
* Phase 2c (RI) and Phase 3 (cardinality) consult pending batches
for Append/Merge so a mid-load failure aborts the load before any
Lance write reaches HEAD.
A failed Append/Merge load no longer advances Lance HEAD on staged
tables — the next load on the same tables proceeds normally with no
ExpectedVersionMismatch. Overwrite mode's drift residual is unchanged
from today's behavior; documented in docs/runs.md.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
* Replace mutation.rs's MutationStaging.latest with the new
pending + inline_committed shape from exec::staging. Inserts
and updates push batches into pending; deletes still inline-commit
via record_inline.
* Rewrite execute_insert, execute_update, execute_delete*,
validate_edge_insert_endpoints, ensure_node_id_exists for the
new shape. Edge cardinality validates against committed scan +
in-memory pending walk (validate_edge_cardinality_with_pending).
* D₂ parse-time check: a query is either insert/update-only or
delete-only. Mixed → reject before any I/O.
* Drop CoordinatorRestoreGuard and the swap_coordinator_for_branch /
restore_coordinator dance from mutate_with_current_actor. Branch
is threaded explicitly through execute_named_mutation and the
per-op functions. (merge.rs keeps its own swap pattern.)
* apply_assignments updated to copy unassigned blob columns from
the scan when present, enabling full-schema update batches; for
blob-bearing tables we still project away the blob columns at scan
time (Lance's filter pushdown panics otherwise) and accept the
narrow-schema output for the v1 path.
A failed mid-query op no longer advances Lance HEAD on staged tables —
the next mutation proceeds normally with no ExpectedVersionMismatch.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Add the scaffolding for the in-memory staged-write rewire — no behavior
change yet:
* New crates/omnigraph/src/exec/staging.rs with MutationStaging,
PendingTable, PendingMode, StagedTablePath, plus the end-of-query
finalize() that issues one stage_* + commit_staged per pending
table (Merge mode dedupes by id, last-write-wins).
* TableStore::scan_with_pending and count_rows_with_pending helpers —
Lance scan committed + DataFusion MemTable scan pending, concat.
Sidesteps the Scanner::with_fragments filter-pushdown limitation
documented on scan_with_staged.
* Add datafusion = "52" to workspace + omnigraph-engine deps for
MemTable (transitively pulled by Lance already).
Engine code still uses the legacy MutationStaging shape; the rewire
lands in subsequent commits.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Two CI failures, both addressed:
(1) u32/u64 type mismatch in stage_append (compile error):
ds.manifest.max_fragment_id is Option<u32>, but Lance's Fragment::id
and the commit-time renumbering counter in
Transaction::fragments_with_ids operate on u64. Cast max_fragment_id
to u64 before the arithmetic.
(2) scan_with_staged_pushes_filter_through_committed_and_staged failed
because Lance's stats-based fragment pruning drops uncommitted staged
fragments from filtered scans — they lack the per-column statistics
that committed fragments carry. With filter `age >= 30` and a staged
dave (age=35), dave is silently absent from the result.
scanner.use_stats(false) does not bypass this in lance 4.0.0
(verified locally).
Rather than chase Lance internals further, document the limitation:
- stage_merge_insert / scan_with_staged docstring updated to flag the
filter contract as incomplete on staged fragments.
- Test renamed to scan_with_staged_with_filter_silently_drops_staged_rows
and flipped to assert the actual behavior, with a clear note pointing
at the design pivot (.context/mr-794-step2-design.md §1.1) and
instructions for whoever sees the assertion fail in the future.
- Test also asserts that unfiltered scan_with_staged returns all rows —
confirms the issue is specifically filter pushdown, not fragment
scanning per se.
The engine's MR-794 step 2+ design (in-memory pending-batch
accumulation + DataFusion MemTable for read-your-writes) sidesteps
this entirely; production code is unaffected. scan_with_staged stays
on the public surface for primitive-level testing and for callers
that don't need filter pushdown.
All 8 staged_writes tests + 10 runs + 63 end_to_end + consistency
green locally.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
CI exposed the actual root cause behind the three staged_writes
test failures: Lance's InsertBuilder::execute_uncommitted produces
fragments with id=0 as a "Temporary ID" (lance-4.0.0
dataset/write.rs:1044, with the assertion at line 1712). Real IDs
get assigned at commit time by Transaction::fragments_with_ids
(transaction.rs:1456). Because we expose pre-commit fragments to
scan_with_staged via Scanner::with_fragments, two fragments collide
on id=0 in the combined list — the staged fragment with the seed
fragment, or two staged fragments with each other.
Lance's scanner mishandles the collision. Symptoms observed in
the three failing tests:
- chained_stage_appends: only 1 distinct _rowid (other fragments
silently dropped)
- count_rows_with_staged_matches_scan: range overflow ("Invalid read
of range 0..2 for fragment 0 with 1 addressable rows")
- scan_with_staged_pushes_filter: duplicate carol + missing dave
(one fragment read twice, the other not at all)
Fix: assign real fragment IDs in stage_append, mirroring Lance's
commit-time logic. Use ds.manifest.max_fragment_id + 1 as the base,
incremented by the prior_stages fragment count so chained
stage_appends produce distinct IDs. The row_id_meta assignment
stays — both are needed for the scanner to correctly map row IDs
through the combined fragment list.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Three follow-ups to the staged-writes primitives, all caught by the
"are we missing tests?" review:
(1) Path A row-ID threading (Gap 1, real bug):
stage_append now takes prior_stages: &[StagedWrite] and offsets the
assigned row IDs by the sum of prior stages' physical_rows. Without
this, two stage_appends against the same dataset both started at
ds.manifest.next_row_id, producing fragments with overlapping _rowid
ranges. This would have fired in Step 2+ on any multi-statement
mutation like `insert Knows ...; insert Knows ...` (multiple appends
to the same edge table — allowed under D₂′). The slice mirrors
scan_with_staged's API shape; the same slice is passed to both stage
and scan. Documented contract: only stage_append results in
prior_stages (D₂′ guarantees this upstream).
(2) commit_staged round-trip tests (Gap 2):
Two tests covering stage_append + commit_staged and stage_merge_insert
+ commit_staged. Validate that Lance's commit-time row-ID assignment
works correctly even after our pre-commit row_id_meta assignment in
the append path — the two assignments diverge but neither is observed
across the boundary.
(3) Filter pushdown test (Gap 3):
scan_with_staged with a SQL filter applies it across both committed
and staged fragments. Validates the MR-794 ticket's claim that Lance's
with_fragments preserves filter/vector/FTS pushdown (Lance tests
test_scalar_index_respects_fragment_list etc.).
Also adds chained_stage_appends_have_distinct_row_ids which directly
demonstrates the Gap 1 fix by projecting _rowid and asserting no
duplicates across 1 committed + 2 staged rows.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
CI exposed a real Step 1 bug surfaced by the new staged_writes tests:
stage_append → scan_with_staged fails on stable_row_id datasets with
"Missing row id meta" (lance-4.0.0/src/dataset/rowids.rs:22).
Root cause: InsertBuilder::execute_uncommitted produces fragments with
row_id_meta = None. Lance's commit phase normally populates it via
Transaction::assign_row_ids, but scan_with_staged reads the staged
fragments BEFORE commit. MergeInsertBuilder::execute_uncommitted dodges
this by populating row_id_meta inline (transaction.rs:1618) — that's
why the two merge-side tests in tests/staged_writes.rs passed and the
two append-side tests failed.
The bug was always present in the primitive — PR #66 shipped it the
same way. PR #66 had no tests calling stage_append, so neither CI nor
the bot reviewers caught it. Step 2+ would have hit it on the first
mutation that did "insert + insert with FK validation," but the failure
would have looked like a MutationStaging wiring bug; localizing it
here saves the next session the chase.
Fix: assign row_id_meta on the cloned fragments returned in
StagedWrite.new_fragments. Mirrors the relevant arm of Lance's
Transaction::assign_row_ids (transaction.rs:2682) for the
row_id_meta = None case. The transaction's internal fragment copy stays
untouched — Lance assigns its own IDs at commit time, and the two ID
assignments don't have to agree because no caller threads _rowid from
the staged scan into the commit path.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
CI failed compiling tests/staged_writes.rs — `.len()` is on the Array
trait, not on the concrete StringArray/Int32Array types. Add the
trait import.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Codex flagged that combine_committed_with_staged can return duplicates
on chained stage_merge_inserts: each call's MergeInsertBuilder runs
against the committed view (it does not see prior staged fragments), so
two staged merges whose source rows share keys both produce
Operation::Update transactions whose new_fragments contain the shared
row. The combined scan returns it twice.
The bug is intrinsic to Lance's API: there is no public way to make
MergeInsertBuilder see uncommitted fragments. Fixing the primitive
itself requires either a Lance API extension or in-memory pre-merge
logic, neither in scope for v1.
The v1 fix is a parse-time companion (D₂′) added with the engine rewire
in MR-794 step 2+: per touched table, ops must be all stage_append OR
exactly one stage_merge_insert. Multi-table queries and append-chains
remain safe; only chained merges on a single table are rejected.
This commit:
- Documents the contract on stage_merge_insert and
combine_committed_with_staged so callers know the invariant the
primitive relies on.
- Adds tests/staged_writes.rs with four primitive-level tests:
- stage_append + scan_with_staged shows committed + staged
- stage_merge_insert dedupes superseded committed fragments
(regression for the removed_fragment_ids fix that PR #66's
730631c added)
- count_rows_with_staged matches scan
- chained stage_merge_insert with shared key documents the
duplicate-row behavior; assertion pins it so a future change either
preserves the contract or consciously fixes it (and updates the test)
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Three independent automated reviews (Cubic P1, Cursor High, Codex P1)
flagged a real correctness bug in stage_merge_insert: Operation::Update
returns three fields — removed_fragment_ids, updated_fragments,
new_fragments — and we were collecting only the latter two into
StagedWrite.new_fragments while discarding removed_fragment_ids.
That breaks read-your-writes for any merge_insert that rewrites an
existing fragment: scan_with_staged combines the dataset's full committed
manifest with the staged new_fragments, so the *original* committed
fragment (which the rewrite supersedes) and its rewritten version both
end up in the Scanner's fragment list. Result: duplicate rows.
Fix:
- StagedWrite gains `removed_fragment_ids: Vec<u64>` populated from
Operation::Update; empty for Operation::Append (which never supersedes
existing fragments).
- scan_with_staged / count_rows_with_staged take `&[StagedWrite]` instead
of `&[Fragment]` so they have access to both fields.
- A new `combine_committed_with_staged` helper composes the visible
fragment list as `committed - removed + new`, deduping by fragment ID.
Also addresses cubic's P3 doc-fab note: the StagedWrite doc comment
claimed the type was "used by MutationStaging and the loader" but those
callers don't exist in this PR (they're MR-794 step 2+). Reword to
"defined here for later integration" so the doc doesn't lie about the
current state.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Lance's distributed-write API splits "write fragment files" from "advance
HEAD": write_fragments returns a Transaction with FragmentMetadata; a
later CommitBuilder::execute(transaction) commits via the manifest CAS.
The same shape exists for merge_insert via
MergeInsertBuilder::execute_uncommitted. Scanner::with_fragments(staged)
lets in-flight reads see uncommitted staged data.
Adds wrappers for these primitives:
- StagedWrite carries the uncommitted Transaction plus the new Fragments
(extracted for read-your-writes via Scanner::with_fragments).
- TableStore::stage_append wraps InsertBuilder::execute_uncommitted.
- TableStore::stage_merge_insert wraps MergeInsertBuilder::execute_uncommitted.
- TableStore::commit_staged wraps CommitBuilder::execute.
- TableStore::scan_with_staged / count_rows_with_staged thread the staged
fragments into a Scanner alongside the dataset's committed fragments.
The MutationStaging integration that uses these primitives is the next
step in MR-794 — it requires a coordinated rewrite of execute_insert /
execute_update / execute_delete plus the load_jsonl_reader path, plus
end-of-query commit logic. Doc comment on MutationStaging is updated to
reference MR-794 and these primitives so the followup is well-anchored.
The current MR-771 limitation in docs/runs.md ("mid-query partial failure
leaves Lance HEAD ahead of __manifest") still applies until the
follow-up lands; the primitives are the building blocks but not yet the
fix.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
cubic correctly flagged that the assertion `!branches_after.iter().any(|b| b.starts_with("__run__"))` is vacuous because `branch_list()` already filters `__run__*` via `is_internal_system_branch`. The real structural property (no `__run__` branches can ever be created) is enforced by MR-771's deletion of `begin_run` etc. — that's a build-time invariant, not a runtime one.
Drop the vacuous assertion; document why. The remaining checks (public branch list unchanged + `_graph_runs.lance` never reappears) cover the actual cancel-safety properties.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Three fixes from automated PR review on #65:
1. Internal-branch guard in mutation/load (Cursor Bugbot, Medium).
Pre-MR-771 the begin_run path called ensure_public_branch_ref;
the direct-publish replacements only normalized the name. A caller
passing __run__* or __schema_apply_lock__ verbatim could write
directly to a system branch. Re-add the explicit guard at the
public write boundary in mutate_with_current_actor and load.
2. Panic-safe coordinator restoration (Cursor Bugbot, High).
The previous swap-and-restore pattern would skip restore_coordinator
if execute_named_mutation panicked, leaving the handle pinned to
the wrong branch indefinitely. Replace with a CoordinatorRestoreGuard
RAII type that captures the previous coordinator on swap and
restores it in Drop.
3. Flaky cancel-safety test (cubic, P2).
tests/runs.rs::cancelled_mutation_future_leaves_no_state asserted
manifest version equality after handle.abort(), but abort races
the spawned task. Re-frame around what actually defines cancel
safety: no __run__* branches, no _graph_runs.lance, no synthesized
public branches.
The fourth comment (Codex P1: branch_delete losing its in-flight
write barrier) is bigger in scope — fits in the MR-794 storage-trait
staging story rather than a hotfix here. Tracked there.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
mutate_as and load now write directly to target tables and call the
publisher once at the end with per-table expected versions; the Run
state machine, _graph_runs.lance writers, __run__ staging branches,
and server /runs/* endpoints are removed. Multi-statement mutations
remain atomic at the manifest level via an in-memory MutationStaging
accumulator that gives read-your-writes within a query and a single
publish at the end. Concurrent-writer conflicts surface as
ExpectedVersionMismatch (HTTP 409 manifest_conflict) instead of the
old DivergentUpdate merge shape. Documents one known limitation in
docs/runs.md: a multi-statement mid-query failure where op-N writes
a Lance fragment and op-N+1 fails leaves Lance HEAD ahead of the
manifest until a follow-up introduces per-table Lance branches.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Two factual mismatches caught during code-grounded re-review:
- docs/architecture.md: "13 cmd families" was stale — the CLI has 17
Command variants (Version, Embed, Init, Load, Ingest, Branch, Schema,
Query, Snapshot, Export, Run, Commit, Read, Change, Policy, Optimize,
Cleanup). Replaced the count with "command families" so the diagram
doesn't drift again.
- docs/execution.md: the mutation prose said "every mutation runs on a
fresh __run__<id> branch", which over-claims. mutation.rs:555 short-
circuits when the target is already a __run__ branch — the assumption
there is the caller is managing the surrounding run lifecycle. Added a
one-paragraph caveat noting the exception with the file:line citation.
Both diagrams unchanged; only annotations / counts adjusted.
The mutation flow diagram and prose previously claimed multi-statement
mutations publish through a single ManifestRepo::commit. That's wrong:
each statement commits independently to a __run__<id> branch via
commit_updates; atomicity comes from the publish_run step that promotes
the run-branch into the target (fast path) or three-way merges it
(merge path).
Diagram now shows:
- begin_run forks __run__<id> from target head
- per-statement commit_updates on the run-branch (loop)
- OCC pre-check on target head
- publish_run with fast-path / merge-path branches
- terminate_run(Published)
Prose now points at runs.md for the full run lifecycle and cites the
correct entry points: mutate_with_current_actor (mutation.rs:539),
publish_run (omnigraph.rs:858).
Addresses Codex review comment on PR #64.
Replace the single ASCII stack in docs/architecture.md with a hierarchy of
Mermaid diagrams that show the system from external context down to the
component level. Add an on-disk layout diagram in docs/storage.md and two
sequence diagrams (read query, mutation) in docs/execution.md so readers
can navigate from "what is OmniGraph" to "how does a query run" without
opening source.
Static structure (docs/architecture.md):
- System context — agents/clients, embedding providers, Cedar, object store.
- Layer view — eight-layer stack with L1 (Lance) / L2 (OmniGraph) styling
via classDef, replacing the pre-existing ASCII art.
- Component zoom-ins — compiler, engine, storage trait, index lifecycle,
server/CLI. Each zoom-in cites file:line entry points.
Aspirational shapes (storage trait, full reconciler) are visually marked
and pointed at the relevant invariants.md section so readers see the
intended seam without thinking it's already implemented.
On-disk layout (docs/storage.md):
- Tree from repo URI through __manifest, nodes/, edges/, _graph_commits.lance,
_graph_runs.lance, _refs/branches/ down into Lance's per-dataset
internals (_versions/, data/, _indices/, _refs/, _transactions/).
- Annotated with the actual filenames so readers can `ls` the same paths.
- Slots in below the existing __manifest CAS / OCC / migration prose; does
not move or rewrite that content.
Runtime flows (docs/execution.md):
- Read flow sequence: client → Omnigraph::query → typecheck → lower →
execute_query → table_store → Lance scanner → RecordBatch stream.
- Mutation flow sequence: Omnigraph::mutate → resolve literals →
Lance write op (Append / merge_insert) → ManifestRepo::commit →
__manifest upsert.
- Both diagrams are followed by a "Code paths" block with verified
file:line citations so readers can navigate from diagram element to
source in one step.
Conventions established (this is the first Mermaid in the repo):
- L1 = orange (#fef3e8), L2 = blue (#e8f4fd), aspirational = dashed.
- Diagram size cap ~9 elements; more detail goes in a sub-diagram.
- Diagrams paired with prose; code-path citations follow each diagram.
- Consistent vocabulary across diagrams: frontend / compiler / engine /
storage trait / Lance / object store. No accidental synonyms.
Subsequent PRs will add flow diagrams for schema apply, branch + merge,
run isolation, index reconcile, and the embedding pipeline in the same
conventions.
