Add diversity-aware selection after Document-RAG reranking (#1014)

* Add Document-RAG diversity selection helper

* Add optional MMR diversity selection after reranking

* Fix Document-RAG diversity test method signatures
This commit is contained in:
YingzuoLiu 2026-07-03 20:35:42 +08:00 committed by GitHub
parent db7fdbc652
commit f04ae5331d
No known key found for this signature in database
GPG key ID: B5690EEEBB952194
5 changed files with 412 additions and 12 deletions

View file

@ -0,0 +1,114 @@
import importlib.util
from pathlib import Path
REPO_ROOT = Path(__file__).resolve().parents[3]
RERANK_PATH = (
REPO_ROOT
/ "trustgraph-flow"
/ "trustgraph"
/ "retrieval"
/ "document_rag"
/ "rerank.py"
)
spec = importlib.util.spec_from_file_location(
"document_rag_diversity_rerank",
RERANK_PATH,
)
rerank = importlib.util.module_from_spec(spec)
spec.loader.exec_module(rerank)
RerankCandidate = rerank.RerankCandidate
normalize_candidate_scores = rerank.normalize_candidate_scores
mmr_select = rerank.mmr_select
_pair_diversity_penalty = rerank._pair_diversity_penalty
def candidate(index, chunk_id, text, score):
return RerankCandidate(
index=index,
chunk_id=chunk_id,
text=text,
reranker_score=score,
)
def test_normalize_candidate_scores_min_max_scales_raw_scores():
candidates = [
candidate(0, "a", "alpha", -2.0),
candidate(1, "b", "beta", 0.0),
candidate(2, "c", "gamma", 4.0),
]
normalized = normalize_candidate_scores(candidates)
assert normalized[0].normalized_score == 0.0
assert normalized[1].normalized_score == 1.0 / 3.0
assert normalized[2].normalized_score == 1.0
def test_normalize_candidate_scores_handles_equal_scores():
candidates = [
candidate(0, "a", "alpha", 3.0),
candidate(1, "b", "beta", 3.0),
candidate(2, "c", "gamma", 3.0),
]
normalized = normalize_candidate_scores(candidates)
assert [c.normalized_score for c in normalized] == [0.5, 0.5, 0.5]
def test_mmr_select_limits_results():
candidates = [
candidate(0, "a", "alpha policy", 0.9),
candidate(1, "b", "beta refund", 0.8),
candidate(2, "c", "gamma shipping", 0.7),
]
selected = mmr_select(candidates, limit=2)
assert len(selected) == 2
def test_mmr_select_prefers_highest_reranker_score_first():
candidates = [
candidate(0, "a", "weakly relevant text", 0.1),
candidate(1, "b", "strongly relevant answer", 10.0),
candidate(2, "c", "medium relevant text", 5.0),
]
selected = mmr_select(candidates, limit=1)
assert selected[0].chunk_id == "b"
def test_mmr_select_penalizes_near_duplicate_chunks():
candidates = [
candidate(0, "a", "apple banana fruit return policy", 1.00),
candidate(1, "b", "apple banana fruit return policy duplicate", 0.95),
candidate(2, "c", "engine motor vehicle warranty", 0.90),
]
selected = mmr_select(
candidates,
limit=2,
lambda_mult=0.2,
token_overlap_weight=1.0,
)
assert [c.chunk_id for c in selected] == ["a", "c"]
def test_pair_diversity_penalty_is_clamped():
left = candidate(0, "a", "same same same", 1.0)
right = candidate(1, "b", "same same same", 0.9)
penalty = _pair_diversity_penalty(
left,
right,
token_overlap_weight=10.0,
)
assert penalty == 1.0

View file

@ -476,3 +476,75 @@ class TestRerankActive:
await rag.query(query="What is the return policy?")
assert reranker.calls == []
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
# 3. Diversity selection: optional MMR after cross-encoder scoring
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
@pytest.mark.asyncio
async def test_diversity_mode_scores_full_candidate_pool_before_selecting(self):
"""
With diversity selection enabled, the cross-encoder should score the full
fetched candidate pool before MMR narrows it down to doc_limit.
"""
clients = build_mock_clients()
reranker = StubReranker([
RerankerResult(document_id="0", query_id="0", score=1.00),
RerankerResult(document_id="1", query_id="0", score=0.95),
RerankerResult(document_id="2", query_id="0", score=0.90),
])
rag = DocumentRag(
*clients,
reranker_client=reranker,
rerank_diversity_mode="mmr",
)
await rag.query(query="What is the return policy?", doc_limit=2)
assert reranker.calls[0]["limit"] == len(ORDERED_CONTENT)
call = rag.prompt_client.document_prompt.call_args
passed_docs = call.kwargs["documents"]
assert len(passed_docs) == 2
@pytest.mark.asyncio
async def test_diversity_mode_selects_less_redundant_context_set(self):
"""
MMR should use cross-encoder scores as relevance while penalizing redundant
chunks, so a slightly lower-scored but less redundant chunk can be selected.
"""
clients = build_mock_clients()
prompt_client, embeddings_client, doc_embeddings_client, fetch_chunk = clients
duplicate_a = "apple banana fruit return policy"
duplicate_b = "apple banana fruit return policy duplicate"
diverse_c = "engine motor vehicle warranty"
async def mock_fetch(chunk_id):
return {
CHUNK_A: duplicate_a,
CHUNK_B: duplicate_b,
CHUNK_C: diverse_c,
}[chunk_id]
fetch_chunk.side_effect = mock_fetch
reranker = StubReranker([
RerankerResult(document_id="0", query_id="0", score=1.00),
RerankerResult(document_id="1", query_id="0", score=0.95),
RerankerResult(document_id="2", query_id="0", score=0.90),
])
rag = DocumentRag(
*clients,
reranker_client=reranker,
rerank_diversity_mode="mmr",
rerank_diversity_lambda=0.2,
)
await rag.query(query="What is the return policy?", doc_limit=2)
call = rag.prompt_client.document_prompt.call_args
passed_docs = call.kwargs["documents"]
assert passed_docs == [duplicate_a, diverse_c]